Both Puzzled Oil Painting by Erskine E. Nicol

Both Puzzled

Erskine E. NicolItem # 856581
Museum Quality Hand Painted Oil Reproduction

Was originally

$291.20

Now only

$203.84
You save 30%
Size:
16 X 22 in
9 Frame Options:
Unframed
$
$
Painting Size: 12" x 16"
16" x 22"
20" x 28"
24" x 33"
28" x 39"
32" x 44"
36" x 50"
40" x 55"
Frame: Unframed - Rolled in a tube
Unframed
GA1326
GA1306
GA1315
GA1510
GA1503
GA1505
GA1307
GA1506
GA1509
GA1323
GA1313
GA1508
GA1330
Gallery Wrap
Finished Size: 30" x 34"
Add to Cart
Add to Cart
Free Shipping to Your Door
100% Satisfaction Guaranteed
  • About Reproduction

    Bring the timeless beauty of Erskine E. Nicol's Both Puzzled into your home with a handmade oil painting reproduction. Carefully recreated on canvas by skilled artists using traditional techniques, this piece captures the delicate brushwork, subtle light, and vibrant color of the original masterpiece. With museum-level quality and rich texture, it brings elegance and artistic depth to any space. Enjoy free shipping and make this masterpiece a part of your personal collection.

  • Original Description

    In Both Puzzled by Erskine E. Nicol (1825–1904), the artist masterfully captures a moment of quiet intrigue through his signature genre painting style. Nicol, a Scottish painter known for his humorous and often poignant depictions of everyday life, presents two figures engaged in a moment of shared bewilderment, their expressive faces and body language evoking a sense of relatable human folly. Executed in the mid-19th century, the work reflects the Victorian fascination with narrative storytelling in art, blending detailed realism with subtle wit. Nicol’s skillful use of chiaroscuro and warm, earthy tones lends the scene a sense of intimacy, while the slightly exaggerated expressions nod to the influence of Dutch Golden Age genre painters like Jan Steen. Though not as widely celebrated as some of his contemporaries, Nicol’s works, including Both Puzzled, offer a charming glimpse into 19th-century social humor and remain valued for their technical precision and narrative warmth.

    For interior styling, Both Puzzled would lend character to a traditional study, a cozy library, or even a creative office space. Its rich, muted palette pairs well with dark wood furniture, leather armchairs, and brass accents, enhancing a sense of vintage sophistication. A medium-sized gilded or walnut frame would complement the painting’s 19th-century origins, while positioning it at eye level in a well-lit alcove or above a mantel ensures it becomes a conversational focal point. To balance its narrative intensity, pair it with simpler decor—think neutral walls or minimal shelving—allowing the artwork’s storytelling to shine. In a modern setting, juxtaposing it with abstract pieces in similar tones could create an intriguing dialogue between past and present. Optimal viewing recommends a smaller to midsize wall (the original dimensions being modest), avoiding overcrowding to let its humorous charm resonate.

  • Lead Time & Shipping

    When you order this oil painting replica, it typically takes 2-3 weeks to paint. If the artwork is more complex, it might need a little more time to ensure the best quality. Once it's ready, we'll send you a photo for your approval. After you give the green light, we'll ship it to you for free.

  • Return & Refund

    We believe in the quality of our hand-painted oil painting reproductions, and your satisfaction is our priority. If for any reason, you are not completely satisfied with your purchase, we offer a 45-day return policy. You can return your artwork within 45 days of receipt and receive a full refund. Please note that the artwork must be returned in the original packaging and in the same condition as it was received.

Add to Cart
100% hand-painted

100% hand-painted

Each and every piece of our artwork is entirely hand-painted by artists with over a decade of experience. Every painting is infused with a unique personality and an unrivaled value, showcasing art in its rawest and most authentic form just for you.

Museum quality

Museum quality

We adhere to museum-level standards in our creation. Each piece of work is reproduced using techniques as close as possible to the original, coupled with the finest paints and canvases, making the color, structure, and texture of every replica as similar as possible to the original.

Top-level materials

Top-level materials

We insist on choosing the best quality paints and canvases from around the world. These selected materials not only offer unparalleled color saturation and durability, but also ensure that the reproductions can withstand the test of time. Only the finest materials can replicate the most authentic artworks possible.

Online proofing

Online proofing

We offer online proofing services, allowing you to be hands-on with every step of the artistic journey. You can personally review and suggest tweaks, and we'll meticulously fine-tune every detail until it aligns with your vision to the tee.

Recent Hand-Painted Oil Reproductions

Explore the latest masterpieces carefully crafted by our talented artists.

Frequently asked questions

  • Is my Both Puzzled reproduction painted by hand?

    Absolutely! Every Both Puzzled reproduction is 100% hand-painted by our team of skilled artists—no mechanical prints or digital reproductions here. We use traditional oil painting techniques on premium canvas, with careful attention to brushwork, texture, and layering to authentically recreate the depth and vibrancy of the original artwork. Our artists typically spend between 2-4 weeks completing each painting, ensuring authentic quality and attention to detail. The result is a reproduction that truly honors the spirit of the original artwork while maintaining the unique character of a handcrafted piece.
  • Can I order an oil painting reproduction that's not in your catalog?

    Yes! We offer custom painting services. If there's a specific artwork or portrait you'd like, simply provide us with the details or an image, and our artists will recreate it for you.
  • Can I customize my Both Puzzled reproduction - like adjusting colors?

    Certainly! We offer customization options for Both Puzzled and other reproductions. Since each piece is hand-painted, we will confirm all details with you before starting and provide photos of the completed artwork for your review once finished. Best of all - if anything isn't perfect, we offer unlimited revisions until you're completely satisfied.
  • Can I see a draft of the artwork before it's finished?

    Yes, we offer online proofing services. Once the initial draft is ready, we'll send you a preview. You can provide feedback, and our artists will make adjustments accordingly.
  • How long does it take to paint my Both Puzzled reproduction?

    It usually takes our meticulous artists about 2-3 weeks to complete an oil painting, depending on the difficulty of the subject.
  • If I select one of your frames, will the painting arrive ready to hang?

    Yes, when you choose our framing service, your painting will arrive ready to hang straight out of the box. Of course, you can also purchase just the reproduction alone - in that case, the artwork will be carefully rolled in a protective tube for shipping, and you'll need to have it stretched and framed yourself.
  • How should I display my Both Puzzled reproduction to achieve the best effect?

    For the best visual impact, hang your Both Puzzled at eye level in a well-lit area, preferably with indirect natural light or soft artificial lighting. Avoid direct sunlight and high humidity areas to protect the artwork.
  • How do I clean and maintain my Both Puzzled reproduction?

    Gently dust the painting with a soft brush or lint-free cloth. Avoid using chemicals or water. If the painting requires deeper cleaning, consult a professional.